fonts.com blog

It’s About Papyrus – Again

by Allan Haley

It is abundantly clear that the cognoscenti of the type and graphic design communities love to hate the Papyrus™ typeface. While not as reviled as the Comic Sans® typeface, Papyrus receives more than its fair share of bad press.

Sure, it’s overused, but that doesn’t make it a bad design – just popular. And Papyrus does tend to show up in less than stellar graphic design solutions – but, if this is the reason for supposedly sophisticated designers reviling the design, it smacks of elitism.

Would I, use the Papyrus? Probably not – but not because it’s a bad design. If I wanted to make a distinctive graphic statement, I would use a typeface with a little less “face time” – one that really would stand out from the crowd.

Which brings me to why I’m writing this. I saw the movie Avatar™ last weekend and was blown away. While the story was little more than a rewriting of “Dances With Wolves,” the cinematography, animation and special effects were virtually beyond belief. Like the original Wizard of OZ™, Gone With the Wind™ and Star Wars™ movies, Avatar has set a new benchmark for film making excellence.

So why are the subtitles for the Na’vi people, the alien protagonists of the film, set in Papyrus? It is the only unimaginative visual aspect of the movie. If the choice were mine, the subtitles would have been original calligraphy. (There are times when custom handlettering is the perfect answer.) One would think that, in the $300,000,000+ budget for Avatar, there would have been some room for hiring a lettering artist or calligrapher. If there was only $30 allotted to the subtitle typeface (which appears to be the case), designs like ITC Noovo™, ITC Tempus™ Sans, Briem™ Script or Carolina™ would have carried off the alien and beautifully exotic demeanor of the Na’vi quite well – and would not have reminded the audience of a restaurant menu.

Script Font Samples

Allan Haley
Allan Haley is Director of Words & Letters at Monotype Imaging. Here he is responsible for strategic planning and creative implementation of just about everything related to typeface designs.


Tags: , , , , ,

38 Responses to “It’s About Papyrus – Again”

  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Fonts.com, Dan Nisbet and Nathanael Bass, Cassie. Cassie said: RT @Fontscom: Blog Post: It’s about Papyrus – again http://blog.fonts.com/?p=441 […]

  2. […] More: It’s about Papyrus – again | fonts.com blog […]

  3. […] More: It’s about Papyrus – again | fonts.com blog […]

  4. Chris says:

    Good point about typographic “elitism”. Comic Sans and Papyrus are both well designed fonts. It’s not their fault they’re popular and distinctive.

  5. Ryan says:

    I disagree with the elitist aspect of ridiculing certain fonts. Comic Sans is not designed for making signs or writing essays. It’s designed for use in comic books. It’s overuse in the wrong situations, from menus to break-room signs to 40-point email headlines, is ugly and distracting and deserves all the mockery we can lay upon it.

    The same goes for Papyrus, though to a lesser extent. Though I did see an intern use it for body text in a memo one time.

  6. Mark says:

    No comic book letterer who ever wants to be hired would use Comic Sans in a book. Unless of course the scene was making fun of a printed page or website that was using Comic Sans. And even then, that letterer would probably feel dirty in his or her soul.

  7. Michael says:

    Actually, given that we have to believe that the subtitles are an accurate and neutral translation of the Na’vi people, surely Helvetica would be the ideal font to just do the job and get out of the way.

  8. Jenny says:

    it’s not about how it’s overused. It’s the lack of aesthetics that are implied when using the font. It’s just an easy way to get a certain look; like a native, cultural look that people just assume they’ll achieve with applying papyrus on microsoft word.

    I think papyrus deserves that hate…seriously, people who are not design/art majors need to understand this. avoid comic sans and papyrus! quality control.

  9. The Wolfman says:

    In werewolf folklore, like vampires, they are known to have an animlistic allure. Perhaps this what attracted her to him once he was bitten.

  10. […] No comments yet. … comments on this post. TrackBack URI. Leave a comment. Name (required) …It’s about Papyrus again | fonts.com blogIt is abundantly clear that the cognoscenti of the type and graphic design communities love to hate […]

  11. slip_slidden says:

    Never use a preloaded font for any important project. Ever. That said, I wish I were blue. Oh, and I love that tail.

  12. Mahlzeit
    Sehr gelungener Post. Da hat mich Yahoo wie schon so oft an einen super Blog geschickt.
    Feed abonniert
    Viele Grüße aus Gronau

  13. One has to wonder what the ultimate outcome of all of this will be — that said, great viewpoints yet again on this topic — and your blog continues to be a top class supplier of information.

  14. One has to question what the eventual end result of all of this will be — that said, outstanding viewpoints once more on this topic — and your web blog remains a top class supply of information.

  15. streaming 2 says:

    Great Blog I love the lay out and the color scheme is it possible to get a copy of your theme? Please send me an email at JoanBm3@gmail.com

  16. Excellent ideas here, have emailed my mum so expect a big reply!!

  17. nice great blog yea nice work our blog will soon be adding reviews on websites and add them to our websites as the top best 100 websites to visit we also do reviews on Customer Reviews all types of reviews

  18. I am also very big movie fan,superb posting.

  19. Anonymous says:

    Very super information.

  20. majalah wanita says:

    Great Post. I would love to read more in future. keep up the good work.

  21. cleaning rates says:

    hopefully this post doesn’t appear several times (it seems to freeze once i try to post my comment.. not sure if it’s actually posting), but all I really wanted to say was good post and thanks for sharing.

  22. Tarsha Lewelling says:

    Finding websites with as much information as this one is always a pleasure I wll be sure to come back and visit again real soon, keep up the good work.

  23. Web Site Hosting Review…

    My blog is about web free hosting…

  24. cleaning prices says:

    Hey You’ve got a great blog here! I’m definately going to bookmark you. I have a MLM Tips website which pretty much covers Automatic Lead Generation, Website Traffic, SEO and Basically how to Conquer The Internet for your Business. Come check it out when you have time.

  25. housekeeping services says:

    I really such as the posting I’ll be relating back again.

  26. Bookmarked…

    Very useful post. Bookmarked. Thanks for it!…

  27. Inspirator says:

    Hallo, danke für den Beitrag, ich werde ihn nacher auf mein Blog weiterempfehlen.

  28. free style music says:

    I really appreciate what you post.

  29. It’s a good blog…

    I will make sure and bookmark this page and be back to follow you more.…

  30. Watch Movies For Free says:

    Good post thanks

  31. Watch Movies For Free Online says:

    Hey You’ve got a great blog here! I’m definitely going to book­mark you.

  32. kancoll says:

    Good point about typo­graphic “elit­ism”.
    blog

  33. Great Post!…

    […] I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :) […]…

  34. Good Post…

    Guys i liked this blog and entry, i wanted to share with you.…

  35. dodge dakota truck cap says:

    I am excited already as I know you always have pretty cool stuff.

  36. electronic free project schematic says:

    Hi There
    Just wanted to say HI. I found your site a few days ago on Technorati and I and have been reading it over the past few days.
    I love dha site template

  37. […] in das Spielhälften von je 45 Minuten Dauer Arme. Verkaufe ein neues Iphone × 45 It’s about Papyrus – again | fonts.com blog Minuten, jedoch gibt es auch Variationen, bei der Überraschung. Juni ist ein Testspiel […]

  38. 2 bond james man poor says:

    Way cool stuff, will have to try it. By da way, down load link does not work. Can you please help? thanks
    Really enjoy your blog. gracias
    Bye Bye

Great type makes sites stand out