They’re Electronic Devices – Not Books

by Allan Haley

E-books are the hot new electronic device. For those unfamiliar with the frenzy of these new electronic marvels, an E-book, as defined by the Oxford Dictionary, is “an electronic version of a printed book which can be read on a personal computer or hand-held device designed specifically for this purpose.” An E-reader is a lightweight device specifically developed for downloading and displaying these materials page by page. Amazon’s Kindle™ E-reader was the first on the market, Barnes and Noble followed with the Nook™, and there are now over thirty more in one stage or another of development.

These devices, however, are not books. They are readers. Books have pages that turn, they have a heft and a smell, you can dog-ear their pages, you can press flowers in them – and they are put on a shelf when you are done with them for the time being. E-readers will not replace books – at least not all books.

First, because E-readers, at about $200, are relatively expensive – and you still have to purchase books for them. Eventually, the price will come down, but there will still be many people that cannot afford the devices and would like to continue purchase their books from a bookstore or borrow them from a library.

Next, there are some books that cannot be replaced – at least with current E-reader technology. Children’s books that you read to your nieces and nephews, sons and daughters, and grandchildren when they snuggle up next to you on a sofa, come to mind. Art books will continue to be published in traditional form. E-readers will probably not replace books on graphic design – and certainly not books on typography. (He wrote with tongue firmly planted in cheek.)

E-readers, however can be a strong competition to books for entertainment. You may eagerly anticipate Dan Brown’s next novel. You may thoroughly enjoy reading it. But, when you are done, what do you do with it? Put it on a shelf where it will sit until you decide to throw it out. Unless it’s a signed first edition, Dan Brown’s new novel will have little value once it is read. That’s where e-readers come in. When you are done with an E-book, you can simply delete it from the E-reader and it will be stored in the cloud for you for future use.

You can also put over 1,000 E-books – or many very big E-books – on a single E-reader. Required reading for scholars, educators, students and professionals in the technical trades is today satisfied by many – heavy – books. E-readers can be a godsend to these folks. One E-reader has to be better than carrying 30-pounds of traditional books in a backpack.

To become more mainstream, however, E-readers will also need to improve their typographic presentation. One or two fonts are simply not enough. Kerning, line spacing, paragraphing, column alignment, and all those other typographic details we sweat over as designers, and appreciate as readers, will have to be addressed in a much better fashion. Technology has done a pretty good job of putting words and letters on digital substrata. It will, however, take the knowledge, skill and, yes, the passion that we put into traditional graphic communication, for E-readers to make much of a dent in real book sales.

Allan Haley
Allan Haley is Director of Words & Letters at Monotype Imaging. Here he is responsible for strategic planning and creative implementation of just about everything related to typeface designs.

Tags: , , , ,

64 Responses to “They’re Electronic Devices – Not Books”

  1. I appreciate you for maintaining such a useful portal. this blog was not just informative but also very inventive too. We come across a limited number of professionals who are capable of write not so easy articles that creatively. I are on the lookout for articles about this subject. We ourselves searched in many blogs to come across knowledge with respect to this.I will keep coming back !!

  2. Hello. This is kind of an “unconventional” question , but have other visitors asked you how get the menu bar to look like you’ve got it? I also have a blog and am really looking to alter around the theme, however am scared to death to mess with it for fear of the search engines punishing me. I am very new to all of this …so i am just not positive exactly how to try to to it all yet. I’ll just keep working on it one day at a time Thanks for any help you can offer here

  3. Make100Now says:

    Have you guys seen this?…

    I saw this great post today and it reminded me of a moment of my life.…

  4. slip_slidden says:

    Let’s not forget the fairly recent debacle when Amazon remotely deleted digital editions of “1984” from the Kindles of readers who had bought those editions. I think a major concern should be the mutable nature of digital information. At least a paper book can only be altered by burning. Protect paper books. Protect the future.

  5. Was trying this goto a random blog feature on randomizer and ended up here, a terrific way to read something new like this. Thanks for taking your time and effort to publish this blogpost.

  6. Very great information.

  7. Hi, Very interesting article you have there. I actually run a couple of blogs on this topic, and since I have found some of your articles very informative I definatelty think that my members would enjoy reading them. With that said I would like to place a link to some of your articles on my blogs since they are more detailed than the information posted on my blogs. Thanks for your help!

  8. busic says:

    […] 8:00 pm. This is a great post, Thanks! Leave a Reply. Cancel. Name (required) Mail (will not be …They’re electronic devices not books | blogE-books are the hot new electronic device. For those unfamiliar with the frenzy of these new […]

  9. Your website has a lot of useful information. Glad you’ve taken the time to share it with us.

  10. Such an excellent idea. One of my favorites this month!

    Rachael West

  11. Hi, just found your blog after browsing via some other blogs whie searching for book review. I really like the way you write, keep up the good work, thank you.

  12. Such an excellent idea. One of my favorites today!

    Rachael West

  13. Issac Maez says:

    saw this post posted on digg and opened it. after reading i’ll make sure to digg it as well. thanks! looking forward for more!

  14. watch 5000 tv channels for free says:

    Fine blog,have a fine day

  15. To my opinion to increase traffic you should write and submit articles . It is a classic, but it works. This will be indefinite traffic stuck in the search engines for you. Write quality unique articles, not articles that are rehashed or provide no insight to readers, which is a huge problem these days.

  16. kindle case says:

    I really enjoyed reading about They’re electronic devices – not books | blog and thought it was well worth the read. The only other site I enjoyed was because they seemed very insightful as well.

  17. Neat blog, some interesting details. I believe 8 of days ago, I have found a similar post. Does anyone know how to track future posts?

  18. thx for this one m8

  19. Our Blog…

    Nice Info. Thank you sir.…

  20. I want to say – thank you for this!

  21. lasik says:

    I rarely leave comments on articles, but your article encouraged me to compliment your writings. Thanks for the info, I will tweet your site and come back occasionally.

  22. To my opinion to increase traffic you can do blogging, and create a link back to your site, but you have to look those do follow blog sites. Social bookmarking is also great.

  23. Leo Karmazyn says:

    Thank you for your help!

  24. definitely enjoyed every aspect

  25. VPS Reviews says:

    Great Post.… Thanks :)

  26. tarick says:

    Merci pour cette article, un info utile merci !

  27. Un ami m’a conseillé cet article, et je ne suis pas décu!

  28. Really nice writing.

  29. Excellent post. Can’t wait to see the next blog post.

  30. Caleb Rousch says:

    Vraiment un très bon article, merci encore ;)

  31. I like it very much.

  32. Love this article. Where did you find this information?

  33. Arturo Mauldin says:

    Fantastic site I have been looking for such information for a long time, glad to have found it and will come again soon. Thanks

  34. Zahra Al Khaleej says:

    Can i use this blog post as a reference. I am thinking to create my post out of this and give my own insight.. I hope you don’t mind

  35. Marjory Sivak says:

    I in der Regel nicht in Blogs post aber Ihr design mich gezwungen, unglaubliche Arbeit geleistet .. beautiful …

  36. telanjang says:

    Hey, guy, your blog is nice. It can bring me many useful information.

  37. Irmgard Knerien says:

    Considerably, the article is really the freshest on this valuable topic. I harmonise with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your incoming updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the tremendous lucidity in your writing. I will directly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. Admirable work and much success in your business enterprize!

  38. ACMAT says:

    (Salut | Bienvenue | Salut HI) They’re electronic devices – not books | blog premičre fois (sauté | borné | houblonné |) sauté ici sur votre site, Founde sur (Google | Yahoo | Bing | ASK). C’est ma premičre impression avant de commenter le contenu. Je suis ravie de trouver votre site en ligne magnifique. Je cherche manusl utilisateur (| manuels en PDF | manuel du propriétaire). J’ai trouvé magasin avec manusl utilisateur (| manuels en PDF | manuel du propriétaire) par regarder gratuitement manusl (utilisateur | manuels en PDF | manuel du propriétaire). Avez-vous actuellement un site Web gratuit avec PDF? ACMAT Envoyez-moi des nouvelles de

  39. echourouk-online says:

    Great article, I’m an avid reader of your blog, keep up the great work, and I’ll be a regular visitor for a very long time.

  40. Burton Haynes says:

    This was a very good post, I found it to not only be very helpful infomation but also touched on what I was researching in good detail. Keep up the work!

  41. majalah wanita says:

    Great thread. Enjoyed the posts…

  42. peter says:

    poignant post. to be truthful i am not sure i got every point completely. but, wanted to chip in and leave a note anyway. are you a journalist by vocation?, because your blog is really good.

  43. Lynsey Femia says:

    Some webmasters try to use articles from available substance directories to get visitors to their internet site and make some money. This is mostly important for those who have just begun working as an affiliate for different companies and do not even have any funding, yet need to develop small niche internet sites to visitants to their internet site so that they can start making revenue.

  44. Delphi_Pro says:

    Why are some of these fonts so outrageously priced? Some are even over $1,000! Why would someone want to spend that much on a font when you can buy a whole new computer for that amount?

  45. Gagner au Casino says:

    Un ami m’a conseillé cet article, et je ne suis pas décu!

  46. john says:

    excellent post. to be truthful i am not sure i understood your point completely. but, wanted to stop inand leave a note anyway. are you a journalist by trade?, because your blog is really strong.

  47. says:

    Merci pour cet article ;)

  48. Clyde Mleczko says:

    Un petit merci pour cet article.

Great type makes sites stand out