They’re Electronic Devices – Not Books

by Allan Haley

E-books are the hot new electronic device. For those unfamiliar with the frenzy of these new electronic marvels, an E-book, as defined by the Oxford Dictionary, is “an electronic version of a printed book which can be read on a personal computer or hand-held device designed specifically for this purpose.” An E-reader is a lightweight device specifically developed for downloading and displaying these materials page by page. Amazon’s Kindle™ E-reader was the first on the market, Barnes and Noble followed with the Nook™, and there are now over thirty more in one stage or another of development.

These devices, however, are not books. They are readers. Books have pages that turn, they have a heft and a smell, you can dog-ear their pages, you can press flowers in them – and they are put on a shelf when you are done with them for the time being. E-readers will not replace books – at least not all books.

First, because E-readers, at about $200, are relatively expensive – and you still have to purchase books for them. Eventually, the price will come down, but there will still be many people that cannot afford the devices and would like to continue purchase their books from a bookstore or borrow them from a library.

Next, there are some books that cannot be replaced – at least with current E-reader technology. Children’s books that you read to your nieces and nephews, sons and daughters, and grandchildren when they snuggle up next to you on a sofa, come to mind. Art books will continue to be published in traditional form. E-readers will probably not replace books on graphic design – and certainly not books on typography. (He wrote with tongue firmly planted in cheek.)

E-readers, however can be a strong competition to books for entertainment. You may eagerly anticipate Dan Brown’s next novel. You may thoroughly enjoy reading it. But, when you are done, what do you do with it? Put it on a shelf where it will sit until you decide to throw it out. Unless it’s a signed first edition, Dan Brown’s new novel will have little value once it is read. That’s where e-readers come in. When you are done with an E-book, you can simply delete it from the E-reader and it will be stored in the cloud for you for future use.

You can also put over 1,000 E-books – or many very big E-books – on a single E-reader. Required reading for scholars, educators, students and professionals in the technical trades is today satisfied by many – heavy – books. E-readers can be a godsend to these folks. One E-reader has to be better than carrying 30-pounds of traditional books in a backpack.

To become more mainstream, however, E-readers will also need to improve their typographic presentation. One or two fonts are simply not enough. Kerning, line spacing, paragraphing, column alignment, and all those other typographic details we sweat over as designers, and appreciate as readers, will have to be addressed in a much better fashion. Technology has done a pretty good job of putting words and letters on digital substrata. It will, however, take the knowledge, skill and, yes, the passion that we put into traditional graphic communication, for E-readers to make much of a dent in real book sales.

Allan Haley
Allan Haley is Director of Words & Letters at Monotype Imaging. Here he is responsible for strategic planning and creative implementation of just about everything related to typeface designs.

Tags: , , , ,

64 Responses to “They’re Electronic Devices – Not Books”

  1. They’re electronic devices – not books | blog…

  2. acai reviews says:

    That was a great read, where did you discover how to write like that? Whatever the case, your amazing talents has kept us mesmerized in your work. Your inputs are highly appreciated.

  3. Video Games says:

    Thanks for the great post as usual. Back to playing my Wii now :)

  4. Santos Saffell says:

    Found your blog and decided to have a quick read, not what a normally do but nice one. Nice to see a blog for a change that isn’t full of spam and rubbish, and actually makes some sense. Anyway, nice write up.

  5. Deedee Norsen says:

    Cellular blogging is an exciting phenomenon that iscrossing the blogosphere. One of the reasons why a lot of bloggers are drawn to the medium of blogging in first place is that they enjoy being able to dofrequent updates and posts that keep all of their visitors up to speed with currentsituations. Mobile blogs, or“moblogs,” take this to the extreme by providing users to post things literally as they occur. This new wave of moblogs and mobloggers keep network surfers up to date with good and bad eventsissues of importance as they occur all over the world, helping to make worldcommunication quicker and more correct. Many individuals feel that the limitations of blogging have a lot to do with geographics. After all, there is only solive that a blog can be when you need to run home and boot up in order to update it. However, mobile blogging marks the beginning of a exciting new era when web-based communication can happen spontaneously from any position. Moblogging devices mean that there is almost nowhere on the planet thatstays off-limits for bloggers. Next part following week.

  6. amazon kindle 3 says:

    You’ll find two options. The very first option is that it is possible to buy newspapers in Kindle edition, as you’ll be able to discover inside link beneath. Newspapers in Kindle version is much less expensive than paper edition.The 2nd choice would be to use the Kindle’s world-wide-web browser and free of charge world wide web entry, to go to news websites like google news or yahoo news.Both the Kindle 2 as well as the Kindle DX are very good, but if for reading newspapers Kindle DX will probably be much better. This review can help you choose which one to obtain:

  7. hand sweat problems says:

    Remarkable information. Where did you acquired all the information from

  8. Patterson Parks says:

    Is eating only every other day good for you?

  9. Pam says:

    Great article thanks for sharing..

  10. Freeze Dried Acai says:

    I found your blog on bing and read several of your other blog posts. I just added you to my news reader. I look forward to reading more from you in the future. Keep up the good work.

  11. 1969 dodge challenger says:

    Hi Homie
    Great post. I will read your posts frequently.
    What do you know about strange?

  12. acaipure says:

    Good Day
    The download didnt work for me, thank you extremely much for teh info though
    my homie have a website aswell.

  13. images says:

    Ive been reading along for a while now.
    Would you be interested in exchanging site roll

  14. images from electronics1 net says:

    Yo Bro
    Wow! thx! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your post to my blog?
    Good Bye

Great type makes sites stand out