They’re electronic devices – not books

by Allan Haley

E-books are the hot new elec­tronic device. For those unfa­mil­iar with the frenzy of these new elec­tronic mar­vels, an E-book, as defined by the Oxford Dic­tion­ary, is “an elec­tronic ver­sion of a prin­ted book which can be read on a per­sonal com­puter or hand-held device designed spe­cific­ally for this pur­pose.” An E-reader is a light­weight device spe­cific­ally developed for down­load­ing and dis­play­ing these mater­i­als page by page. Amazon’s Kindle™ E-reader was the first on the mar­ket, Barnes and Noble fol­lowed with the Nook™, and there are now over thirty more in one stage or another of development.

These devices, how­ever, are not books. They are read­ers. Books have pages that turn, they have a heft and a smell, you can dog-ear their pages, you can press flowers in them – and they are put on a shelf when you are done with them for the time being. E-readers will not replace books – at least not all books.

First, because E-readers, at about $200, are rel­at­ively expens­ive – and you still have to pur­chase books for them. Even­tu­ally, the price will come down, but there will still be many people that can­not afford the devices and would like to con­tinue pur­chase their books from a book­store or bor­row them from a library.

Next, there are some books that can­not be replaced – at least with cur­rent E-reader tech­no­logy. Children’s books that you read to your nieces and neph­ews, sons and daugh­ters, and grand­chil­dren when they snuggle up next to you on a sofa, come to mind. Art books will con­tinue to be pub­lished in tra­di­tional form. E-readers will prob­ably not replace books on graphic design – and cer­tainly not books on typo­graphy. (He wrote with tongue firmly planted in cheek.)

E-readers, how­ever can be a strong com­pet­i­tion to books for enter­tain­ment. You may eagerly anti­cip­ate Dan Brown’s next novel. You may thor­oughly enjoy read­ing it. But, when you are done, what do you do with it? Put it on a shelf where it will sit until you decide to throw it out. Unless it’s a signed first edi­tion, Dan Brown’s new novel will have little value once it is read. That’s where e-readers come in. When you are done with an E-book, you can simply delete it from the E-reader and it will be stored in the cloud for you for future use.

You can also put over 1,000 E-books – or many very big E-books – on a single E-reader. Required read­ing for schol­ars, edu­cat­ors, stu­dents and pro­fes­sion­als in the tech­nical trades is today sat­is­fied by many – heavy – books. E-readers can be a god­send to these folks. One E-reader has to be bet­ter than car­ry­ing 30-pounds of tra­di­tional books in a backpack.

To become more main­stream, how­ever, E-readers will also need to improve their typo­graphic present­a­tion. One or two fonts are simply not enough. Kern­ing, line spa­cing, para­graph­ing, column align­ment, and all those other typo­graphic details we sweat over as design­ers, and appre­ci­ate as read­ers, will have to be addressed in a much bet­ter fash­ion. Tech­no­logy has done a pretty good job of put­ting words and let­ters on digital sub­strata. It will, how­ever, take the know­ledge, skill and, yes, the pas­sion that we put into tra­di­tional graphic com­mu­nic­a­tion, for E-readers to make much of a dent in real book sales.

14 Responses to “They’re electronic devices – not books”

  1. pc news…

    …if this guy insists on water­ing down seo we will have no choice but to let the dogs out.…

  2. I appre­ci­ate you for main­tain­ing such a use­ful portal. this blog was not just inform­at­ive but also very invent­ive too. We come across a lim­ited num­ber of pro­fes­sion­als who are cap­able of write not so easy art­icles that cre­at­ively. I are on the lookout for art­icles about this sub­ject. We ourselves searched in many blogs to come across know­ledge with respect to this.I will keep com­ing back !!

  3. Hello. This is kind of an “uncon­ven­tional” ques­tion , but have other vis­it­ors asked you how get the menu bar to look like you’ve got it? I also have a blog and am really look­ing to alter around the theme, how­ever am scared to death to mess with it for fear of the search engines pun­ish­ing me. I am very new to all of this …so i am just not pos­it­ive exactly how to try to to it all yet. I’ll just keep work­ing on it one day at a time Thanks for any help you can offer here

  4. Ulti­mate Acai Berry…

    Look­ing for a quick and easy way to stay in form? Did you know that acai berry can help you with that?…

  5. Make100Now says:

    Have you guys seen this?…

    I saw this great post today and it reminded me of a moment of my life.…

  6. slip_slidden says:

    Let’s not for­get the fairly recent debacle when Amazon remotely deleted digital edi­tions of “1984” from the Kindles of read­ers who had bought those edi­tions. I think a major con­cern should be the mut­able nature of digital inform­a­tion. At least a paper book can only be altered by burn­ing. Pro­tect paper books. Pro­tect the future.

  7. Sonny Alyea says:

    Hi There! Great post. I totally agree with that. I recently star­ted out play­ing online poker.I used a non deposit bonus and turned $150 into $750 already.I am still a noobie but the poker­school has a great the­ory sec­tion. Why dont you try it out aswell? $150 No Deposit Bonus to start your Poker­car­reer withour any risk: Poker­school and $150 free Pokereducation

  8. Susan Miller says:

    My girl­friends an myself have been get­ting a great weight loss product at this web­site, Has any­body tried it so I can add some feed­back. It’s at Buy Acai Berry. Let us know what you think.. thx!

  9. Antony Busic says:

    Thanks for this good read. I’ll come back on a break from this flor­ist in Oakville

  10. Was try­ing this goto a ran­dom blog fea­ture on ran­dom­izer and ended up here, a ter­rific way to read some­thing new like this. Thanks for tak­ing your time and effort to pub­lish this blogpost.

  11. Hi, Very inter­est­ing art­icle you have there. I actu­ally run a couple of blogs on this topic, and since I have found some of your art­icles very inform­at­ive I definatelty think that my mem­bers would enjoy read­ing them. With that said I would like to place a link to some of your art­icles on my blogs since they are more detailed than the inform­a­tion pos­ted on my blogs. Thanks for your help!

Leave a Reply